Assistant EmpireBrand outreach · Since 2020 Send my brief Send brief

For brands · 17 min read

How to Find the Right Influencers for Your Brand (and Vet Them Before You Pay)

Learn how to find influencers for your brand for free, vet micro-influencers with a scoring sheet, and send a first offer creators can answer fast.

HarryFounder, Assistant Empire ·

To find the right influencers for your brand, write a one-line brief, then search customer tags, niche keywords, competitor partnerships, and creator referrals. Vet each candidate’s last 10–12 comparable posts, comment quality, audience location, and past sponsored work. In your first email, state the budget, deliverables, usage rights, and dates so creators can answer fast.

What should you decide before you search for influencers?

Start with the job you are hiring for. It decides who belongs on the shortlist.

If you want reach and trust, you need an influencer whose audience matches your buyer. A neighborhood restaurant trying to fill weekday tables needs creators whose viewers live nearby. If you want footage, such as ad creative or product demos for your own channels, you need a content creator. Then on-camera clarity, pacing, and usage rights matter more than audience size. The same food creator could do either job, but you would vet them differently.

Turn the campaign into a one-line brief so everyone sourcing candidates looks for the same proof:

Find [platform and format] creators in [niche] who reach [buyer,
market, and language], ideally [follower range], who already show
[proof of fit], for [deliverable and goal] in [window] at [budget per creator].

A running brand might write: Find Instagram Reel creators in running who reach US first-time half-marathoners, ideally 10k–75k followers, who already film training runs and answer shoe-fit questions, for one paid wear-test Reel in a spring launch window at $600–$1,000 per creator. A Reel where the creator answers shoe-fit questions in the comments is the kind of proof I’d save.

Split the brief into hard requirements and preferences. If you only ship in the US, US audience share is a requirement, while follower count can flex if the creator reliably reaches the right buyers. If you plan to run the content as a paid ad or want competitor exclusivity, budget for it now instead of raising it after the creator quotes. Finally, name who approves fees and how you will judge the campaign: local reach, clicks, tracked orders, or usable ad assets.

Where can you find influencers for your brand for free?

You don’t need a paid database to build a strong first shortlist. If customers already tag you, start with your own mentions. If the product is new, start with native search and complementary brands.

Speed below is a rough planning guide. Creator fees are separate from what it costs to find them.

Sourcing route Cost to search Speed Best for
Your own tags, mentions, and customers Free Fast if you already get mentions Creators who already use and like the product
Native keyword, hashtag, and location search Free Fast to start; vetting is manual Micro-influencers, local creators, specific formats
Competitor and complementary brand posts Free Fast in active categories Creators with proven sponsored work and aligned buyers
Referrals and niche communities, including Reddit Free to ask Depends on replies Specialist niches, local markets, peer-recommended voices
Platform creator marketplaces Varies by platform and account Fast once you have access Single-platform campaigns and partnership ads
Discovery tools, opt-in marketplaces, or a managed shortlist Free and paid options Fast list-building; vetting still needed Cross-platform filtering, inbound applications, limited staff time

Your own tags, mentions, and customers. Check tagged posts, mentions, and reviews first. Search your product name without the @ handle too, because plenty of buyers talk about a product without tagging it. When a customer posts an unprompted tutorial or honest review, save that post. An email that opens with “We saw how you used our product in Tuesday’s video” starts well ahead of a cold pitch.

Native keyword, hashtag, and location search. Search the phrases your buyer types, not industry labels: wide toe box running shoes, Chicago gluten-free bakery, small apartment entryway storage. On Instagram, check Reels, niche hashtags, and location tags. On TikTok, open the profile behind a helpful video to confirm the topic is a regular theme, not a one-off viral clip. On YouTube, search the comparison and how-to questions your buyer watches before buying. On LinkedIn, search posts about your buyer’s workflow and note who adds practical commentary. Sprout Social’s guide to finding the right influencers covers both native hashtag search and LinkedIn as discovery routes.

Competitor and complementary brands. Look at competitors’ tagged posts and disclosed ads, then look one category over. If you sell meal-prep containers, creators who teach weekly batch cooking often give your product a more natural role than general kitchen-gadget reviewers. Note the format, whether viewers asked buying questions, and whether a recent deal with a direct competitor could cause an exclusivity conflict.

Referrals and niche communities. Ask creators you admire who else serves the same audience. A creator who is booked or over budget can still point you to peers that search would never surface:

Hi [Name], thanks for letting me know you're booked for [month].
I really like how you cover [topic]. Are there one or two creators
in the same space you'd recommend for a paid [format] campaign?
Happy to keep you in mind for [next quarter].

On Reddit and niche forums, look for the reviewers, channels, and newsletters members keep recommending. Then vet those creators where they publish and contact them through their business email.

Platform creator marketplaces. If the campaign lives on one network, try the native tools listed in Kolect’s guide to finding influencers: Instagram’s creator marketplace, TikTok One, and YouTube Creator Partnerships. Whatever the filters suggest, still open each creator’s public feed and run the same manual checks.

Discovery tools, opt-in marketplaces, and managed shortlists. A paid database helps when you need to filter across several countries or platforms at once. An opt-in marketplace or an application form on your site lets interested creators come to you. Ask applicants for one relevant post link, their top audience country, and their availability. If someone hands you a shortlist, ask for the evidence behind each pick. Inbound applicants should clear the same vetting bar as creators you find yourself.

How do you find micro-influencers for your brand?

Skip broad labels like parenting influencer or fitness creator. Search a narrow problem plus a format or city, such as stroller-friendly walks Seattle or budget gluten-free meal prep. When you find one strong smaller account, check who they tag, who they collaborate with, and who they recommend in comments. Save the post that proved the fit, because you will use it in your first email.

How do you vet influencers before you pay them?

I’ve worked in social media for 16+ years. I was a social media marketer and branding expert before I started focusing on brand collaborations in 2020. The most expensive mistake I see is paying for follower count instead of steady views and audience fit.

Do a public review of every candidate before you email them. Once there is mutual interest, check private audience data and terms before anyone signs or films.

What should your vetting checklist include?

  • ☐ Median views on the last 10–12 comparable posts. Match the campaign format: Reels for a Reel deal, Shorts for a Shorts deal. Sort the view counts and take the median (with 10 or 12 posts, average the middle two) so one viral hit doesn’t skew it. Leave out giveaways and obviously boosted posts.
  • ☐ Views per follower and engagement on views. Divide median views by follower count, then divide likes plus comments by views on the same posts. Only compare accounts on the same platform and format. Kolect’s guide recommends both checks alongside comment quality.
  • ☐ Comment quality. Read several recent comment sections. Look for buying questions about price, sizing, ingredients, compatibility, or results, and for helpful replies from the creator. Emojis and one-word praise tell you much less.
  • ☐ Audience location and buyer fit. A bio city tells you where the creator films. Analytics tell you who watches. Before booking, ask for recent screenshots of top countries (or cities, for local businesses) and age and gender splits, naming the platform and date range you want. Ask for their media kit at the same time.
  • ☐ Past sponsored posts. Watch two or three past brand integrations in your format and compare their views and comment tone with the creator’s organic posts. Does the product fit the story, or feel bolted on? Ask what results they can share from similar campaigns, such as link taps for a traffic goal.
  • ☐ Brand safety and production quality. Scroll well past the top row for anything that conflicts with your standards: misleading claims, unsafe demos, a clashing tone. Watch at least one full video with sound on to judge audio, captions, lighting, and pacing.
  • ☐ Disclosure habits. Check that past paid and gifted posts were clearly disclosed. In the US, the Federal Trade Commission’s Disclosures 101 for Social Media Influencers says to disclose any financial, employment, personal, or family relationship with a brand (free products count) and to place the disclosure where people will see it with the endorsement. For UK campaigns, follow the ASA and CAP influencers’ guide so ads are obviously identifiable as ads. Put your disclosure rules in the brief and check them at publish.
  • ☐ Competitor exclusivity. Ask whether the creator has an active exclusivity clause covering your category. If you want exclusivity yourself, define the category or named competitors and the duration, and expect to pay extra for it.

What red flags point to fake followers or inflated numbers?

Fake followers. A large following with consistently tiny views and sparse, off-topic comments deserves a closer look. Check whether one viral post, a press feature, or an old giveaway explains the gap, then ask for recent native analytics. In the US, the FTC’s Q&A on the Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule covers the rule’s ban on buying or selling fake indicators of social media influence, such as bot-generated followers or views, to misrepresent influence for a commercial purpose.

Engagement pods. Watch for the same cluster of creator accounts leaving vague praise (“Love this!”, “So good!”) on unrelated posts within minutes of publishing. Loyal fans comment often too, so look for substance: real fans mention something specific or ask a follow-up question.

Giveaway-inflated numbers. “Comment to win” posts measure interest in a free prize, not in the creator’s usual content. Leave them out of your median and judge the creator on ordinary posts and past sponsored work.

How do you score and compare creators?

Score each criterion 0 (poor), 1 (partial), or 2 (strong), and use ? until missing data such as audience location arrives. Don’t book a high scorer who fails a hard requirement on audience location, brand safety, disclosure, or exclusivity.

Criterion 0 (poor) 1 (partial) 2 (strong)
Audience and market fit Wrong buyer or market Some overlap, unverified Clear buyer match, backed by analytics
Content and format fit Rarely makes your format Makes it, uneven quality Makes it regularly and explains well
Median views and comments Weak views or hollow comments Steady views, mixed comments Healthy views and real buying questions
Sponsored work Stiff ads or a sharp view drop Good organic work, few or mixed ads Natural integrations that hold attention
Budget, timing, logistics Over budget or unavailable Close, with small trade-offs Fits budget, window, usage, and shipping

Paste these headers into a spreadsheet to compare candidates side by side:

Creator & handle | Platform | Sourcing route | Best-fit post URL |
Audience fit (0-2/?) | Format fit | Views & comments | Sponsored fit |
Budget & timing | Total (/10) | Median views (last 10-12) |
Views/follower | Analytics requested? | Disclosure, safety & exclusivity |
Quoted fee & usage | Stage | Next action, owner & date | Exit reason

What should you check for your niche?

Each niche has a check or two that generic lists miss. Here is what I’d verify before booking:

Niche What I’d verify before booking
Beauty The creator shows the shade range, undertones, and skin types your buyers have, in honest lighting, and viewers ask real shade-match and wear questions.
Fitness and supplements Safe technique and a creator willing to stick to approved wording. Have your team check every spoken, captioned, and implied health claim against your substantiation, using the FTC’s Health Products Compliance Guidance.
Finance Creators who explain risks and trade-offs for your buyer’s country. For UK campaigns, have compliance confirm whether a post is a financial promotion (finprom) and whether an authorized firm must approve it, per the FCA’s FG24/1 guidance on financial promotions on social media.
Parenting Whether children need to appear at all. Agree in writing with the parent on what can be filmed and reused, and keep schools, routines, and other identifying details out of the brief. A parent-led demo often works as well.
Gaming The creator’s actual games, genres, and platforms (PC, console, mobile). Confirm key or build access dates, embargo time zones, launch windows, and spoiler limits before sending access.
B2B, SaaS, tech and AI Practitioners on LinkedIn who teach the workflow and YouTube creators who demo real use cases. Watch how clearly they explain setup and trade-offs and answer questions in comments.
Food Local audience share for restaurants. For packaged goods: recipes viewers can actually repeat, clear prep shots, and a natural reason to use the product.
Travel Where viewers live (your departure market) and how they travel (budget, family, luxury). Agree on expenses, filming windows, and backup plans for weather or access changes.
Fashion Clear try-ons, sizing notes, and styling across the sizes you stock. Confirm samples and shipping lead times before locking a publish date.
Home Project scale that matches yours (renter-friendly updates vs. full renovations), who handles installation, and what can realistically be filmed on schedule.
Pets The product suits the species, size, and needs of the pet on camera, and the creator can fit it into the pet’s normal routine.

What should your first email to a creator include?

We run brand outreach for creators in every niche, with one dedicated person on each creator’s inbox, so we read a lot of brand emails from the creator’s side. When an inquiry stalls, it is usually for one of these reasons:

  • “Are you open to a collab? Send your rates!” Without deliverables, usage, or dates, a creator can’t quote accurately.
  • Gifting presented as a paid partnership. If there is no cash budget, say so up front. Revealing “gifted only” three emails in burns goodwill.
  • Usage or exclusivity held back until the contract. Whitelisting (ads run through the creator’s handle), paid usage, and category exclusivity all change the price. Raising them late reopens the negotiation.
  • No dates. Creators plan filming around existing sponsors. Without a window, they can’t check availability.

Four details let us answer a brand in one reply: what you are paying (or your range), what you want made, where you will use it, and when you need it. Send the email to the business address or manager listed in the creator’s bio, and open with one specific detail from the post you saved while vetting:

Subject: Paid [format] partnership with [Brand] in [month]

Hi [Name],

I'm [your name] at [Brand]. I liked how you [specific detail from
their post]. We make [product] for [target buyer], and I'd love to
see how you'd show [use case] in your own style.

Here's the scope:
- Deliverables: [quantity, format, platform, any cross-post]
- Budget: [fixed fee or approved range]
- Timeline: draft by [date]; publish [date or window]
- Usage and exclusivity: [organic only, or paid usage channels + term;
  category exclusivity + dates if needed]

Are you available for that window? If so, could you share your media
kit and confirm your rate for this scope? I can send the full brief
right away.

Best,
[Name]
[Role], [Brand]

Our influencer marketing guide for brands covers the rest of the campaign process.

How should you follow up if a creator doesn’t reply?

Creators and managers miss first emails all the time, especially during filming weeks and holidays. Follow up in the same thread after a few business days, then once more about a week later if the window is still open:

Hi [Name], just bumping this in case it got buried. We still have a
spot open for [month] ([deliverables] at [budget or range]). Let me
know if you're available or if another window works better.

A polite chase is usually welcome. When we followed up with Nim for a creator we represent, the brand replied: “Thank you for chasing me”. If a creator declines, thank them and close the thread. If a quote is over budget, ask what it includes and adjust the scope (fewer deliverables, shorter paid usage, no exclusivity) instead of just asking for a discount.

What do real creator inbox threads show?

These come from threads we handled for a tech and AI creator we represent (Instagram Reels and TikTok), pitching brands from the creator’s outreach inbox. They are AI and SaaS examples, but the same process applies in beauty, fitness, food, parenting, or any other niche. Read them from the brand side: each one shows what helps a deal move.

  • Omnisend paid more for a wider scope. Our pitch offered “a fun reel + stories showing exactly how I use Omnisend in real life.” After one follow-up, Omnisend replied: “Thanks for reaching out! This seems amazing!” We quoted: “For this collab, I charge $700 for one Instagram reel along with supporting stories.” The brand countered: “Do you think we can agree on 1000 USD for IG reels with stories and cross-post to you TikTok channel?” We replied, “Yes, that works perfectly for me!” The creator signed the agreement, and the brand approved the script: “Thanks for sending the script. Everything looks good!” Takeaway: if you want an extra placement, such as a TikTok cross-post, name it and price it in the same message.
  • GoHighLevel turned one clear rate into a three-month deal. After our pitch and one follow-up, GoHighLevel asked: “Do you have a media kit? Would love to hear more.” It then asked what the creator charges per Reel. We replied: “I charge $700 per reel. This includes scripting, filming, editing, and one round of revisions if needed.” GoHighLevel answered: “Lets do a 3 month deal with 1 reel per month at $700 per reel. I will send over our contract form to get started!” Takeaway: ask what a rate includes, and if you want recurring content, propose the cadence.
  • ONLYOFFICE came back after two holiday follow-ups. This was a repeat collaboration. ONLYOFFICE wrote, “We are considering collaborations for January, and definitely open for another collaboration,” and we confirmed: “My rate remains the same as our last project at $1500.” The thread went quiet over the holidays. After two short follow-ups in the same thread, the brand replied: “Sorry for the delay, I was out of office during this holiday season. The content brief is attached.” Takeaway: keep repeat deals in one thread and allow extra time around holidays.
  • AutoDS said “we’re in.” That was its reply to a pitch that named a $200 rate. A specific number gives the other side something to say yes to.

These are individual negotiations, not averages. More examples are on our real deals page.

How do you track candidates and rebook the best creators?

Track every prospect in one sheet, using the six stages in Limurse’s creator recruitment guide:

  1. Profile: your one-line brief.
  2. Longlist: raw candidates from your sourcing routes.
  3. Shortlist: vetted and scored.
  4. Contacted: first email and follow-ups sent, with an owner and a next date.
  5. Negotiating: media kit, rate, usage, and timeline under discussion.
  6. Live: contract signed, brief sent, content published, results logged.

Record an exit reason whenever someone drops out: audience mismatch, budget gap, schedule conflict, exclusivity clash, or no reply. After a campaign or two, those notes show whether your brief, budget, or email needs work.

Before anyone films, put deliverables, revision rounds, approval deadlines, usage rights, exclusivity, disclosure requirements, and payment timing in writing. For a new product or channel, start with a small group of creators so you can compare results before you scale spend. Note how reliably each creator communicated and met deadlines, not just the numbers.

When a creator delivers, rebook them, and be ready for the rate to rise once results are proven. In another thread for the tech and AI creator we represent, a repeat deal with Fonzi went from $400 to $500 “given the success” of the first one. Rebooking a proven creator is usually less work than finding and vetting someone new.

Assistant Empire has worked with 1000+ brands and clients across the world since 2020. If you’d rather not build the list yourself, send us your product, target buyer, and campaign window, and we’ll put together a free shortlist of creators who fit your brand.

FAQ

How can I find influencers for my brand for free?

Start with your own tagged posts and customer mentions. Run keyword and location searches on the platforms your buyers use, review competitor and complementary brand partnerships, and ask creators you admire for referrals. A spreadsheet is enough to track it, so your budget can go to the creators.

How do I find micro-influencers on Instagram?

Search specific buyer problems instead of generic hashtags, add a city or neighborhood if location matters, and look through Reels and location-tagged posts. Confirm the topic is a regular theme on each profile, check median views across the last 10–12 Reels, and ask for audience-location insights before booking.

Can I find influencers for my brand on Reddit?

Yes. Search relevant subreddits for the reviewers, YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters members recommend again and again. Then vet those creators on the channels where they publish and contact them through their business email rather than messaging Reddit accounts cold.

How can I tell if an influencer has fake followers?

Don’t rely on one metric. Look for several signs together: a large following with weak median views on comparable posts, generic comments from the same accounts, and sudden follower spikes with no obvious cause. Ask for native analytics and check whether a viral clip or giveaway explains the pattern.

Should I hire an influencer or a content creator?

Hire an influencer when you want reach and trust with their audience. Hire a content creator when you mainly need video or photo assets for your own ads and channels. One person can do both. Just list posting and ad-usage rights separately so both sides can price the full scope.

How much should I budget for a creator partnership?

Get quotes for the same scope so you can compare them: format, number of posts, cross-posts, revision rounds, paid usage period, and exclusivity. Add product, shipping, and any ad spend on top of the creator’s fee. If a quote is over budget, adjust deliverables or usage before walking away.

Sources

For brands

Tell us what you need.

Share your product, your niche and your budget range, and we’ll come back with how we’d approach it.

Brief cardFor brands

Send us a brief.

Product
Your product
Niche
Your niche
Platform
YouTubeInstagramTikTok
Budget
Your budget range
Send my brief

We only use your details to reply to you.